Speaker wire vs smart speakers in a NYC renovation

Published
Updated
Written from our project experience, drafted with AI assistance and reviewed by our team. How we write our guides

Our recommendation for most renovations

Most guidance says to run speaker wire while the walls are open. We advise most clients not to. The wire itself is inexpensive, but it commits the budget to speakers, amplifiers and an equipment location that many households end up not using, and in our experience most clients who have it installed leave it unused and listen on smart speakers.

Smart speakers with spatial audio, such as the Apple HomePod, Sonos Era 300 and Amazon Echo Studio, handle music and streaming content well with no in-wall audio cable. Their requirements are an outlet at each location and strong Wi-Fi. Both are planned during the renovation, and strong Wi-Fi in a brick or plaster house depends on well-placed access points connected by Ethernet.

Which option suits which home
SituationRecommendationWhat to run while walls are open
Most renovations, music and streaming in several roomsSmart speakers with spatial audioEthernet, access point locations and outlets at speaker locations
Audiophile with specific equipment or requirementsPassive speakers on dedicated amplifiersSpeaker wire designed for that system, plus Ethernet
Dedicated theater room with professional AV controlsWired AV systemSpeaker wire and control wiring for that room, plus Ethernet
Owner does not want microphones in the homePassive speakers on streaming amplifiersSpeaker wire to the rooms that need it, plus Ethernet

Most smart speakers contain microphones. Many can be muted, but an owner with privacy concerns may reasonably prefer speakers that have none.

From our projects

For new renovations, we don't recommend wiring speakers unless the homeowner is an audiophile with their own unique requirements or has privacy concerns. Most clients who have it leave it unused and use smart speakers instead. Wiring is really for professional audio, and it offers very little entertainment value unless you have a dedicated movie theater with pro AV controls. Even then, smart speakers can have a leg up because of the content sources.

Our default advice: skip the speaker wire, but run Ethernet, more than you need. Ethernet is cheap, and it can carry power, audio or data.

Run Ethernet instead, and more than you need

Ethernet is the cable to install generously in a renovation. It is inexpensive, and a single run can carry data, power over Ethernet (PoE) or network audio, so it remains useful as equipment changes.

  • Run Ethernet to each planned access point location, typically in the ceiling, and to each television and desk.
  • Add runs to locations where you may want a camera, display, smart-home hub or streaming amplifier later.
  • Home-run each cable to one equipment location rather than connecting room to room.
  • Use cable with the correct listed rating: communications-rated cable in walls, riser-rated cable in shafts between floors and plenum-rated cable in return-air plenums.
  • Label both ends of every cable, leave slack at each end and photograph the open walls with a tape measure in view before they are closed.

The equipment location needs a dedicated outlet and an air path, whether a louvered door, a vent or a small thermostat-controlled exhaust fan, because switches and recorders give off heat. The outlet and circuit are installed by our licensed electrical partner.

When wired speakers are the right choice

Wired audio is really for professional audio and for owners who know what they want from it. In a dedicated theater with professional AV controls, wiring is appropriate, although smart speakers can still have an advantage in content sources. Where wired speakers are chosen, the amplifier sets how many speakers each zone can drive and which apps and voice services the system supports.

Wired multi-room audio architectures
SystemHow it worksBest suited toLimitations
Streaming amplifier per zone (Sonos Amp, WiiM Amp Pro or Amp Ultra, Bluesound Powernode)A compact amplifier drives passive in-ceiling or in-wall speakers for one zoneTwo to six zones, renovations of one or two floorsEach zone needs its own amplifier, outlet and network connection
Central multi-zone amplifier (Sonos Amp Multi, multichannel amplifier with streamers, control-system matrix)Every speaker cable runs back to one equipment rackSix or more zones, gut renovations, new construction, small commercial spacesRequires a ventilated equipment location and more design work

Sonos, WiiM and Bluesound each run their own app, and products from different brands work together mainly through AirPlay 2 or Chromecast. Choose one platform for the house. Two 8-ohm speakers wired in parallel on one channel present a 4-ohm load, so check the amplifier specification before putting several pairs on one output.

If you do run speaker wire: gauges, fire ratings and code

  • Home-run each speaker pair, or each speaker, to the equipment location. Daisy-chaining from room to room ties the system to the amplifier you buy today.
  • Choose the gauge by routed length: 16 AWG for most in-ceiling runs up to about 50 feet at 8 ohms, 14 AWG for 50 to 100 feet or for 4-ohm loads, and 12 AWG for long or high-power runs. Measure the actual path through joists and walls and add 10 to 20 percent.
  • Use 2-conductor cable to each speaker of a stereo pair, or 4-conductor cable (16/4 or 14/4) to a single location where one stereo speaker or later flexibility is planned.

Speaker cable inside walls and ceilings must carry a listed in-wall rating. CL2 is the minimum and CL3 is preferred, because CL3 may replace CL2 but not the reverse. Vertical runs through shafts between floors require riser-rated CL2R or CL3R cable, and ceilings used as return-air plenums, common in small offices, require plenum-rated CL2P or CL3P cable. Lamp cord inside a wall does not meet code. In New York City these rules sit in Article 725 of the 2025 NYC Electrical Code (opens an external site), which is based on the 2020 NEC; on Long Island, where a job is inspected under the 2023 NEC, the cable-type rules are in Article 722 (opens an external site).

Under NYC section 725.136(I), speaker and other Class 2 or Class 3 cable stays at least 2 inches from power conductors unless the power wiring is in raceway or in NM, MC, AC or UF cable, or a fixed nonconductor separates them. Where speaker cable must cross power wiring, it crosses at a right angle. The NYC version of 725.24 also requires exposed cable to be supported by approved non-combustible straps, staples, ties or hangers, which matters in unfinished basements and equipment closets.

Brownstones, plaster, co-ops and rated ceilings

  • Brownstones and row houses: floor joists usually span between the party walls, so a run from the front of the house to the back crosses every joist. The route for any cable is set while the ceiling is open, because fishing the same run through plaster later is slow work.
  • Plaster and masonry: these materials weaken Wi-Fi, which makes wired access points more important for smart speakers. If in-ceiling speakers are chosen, new-construction brackets installed at rough-in give a solid mount and a fixed location.
  • Co-ops and condominiums: many alteration agreements restrict speakers in a ceiling shared with the unit above or require back boxes. Back boxes reduce sound transfer and improve bass response, but they do not eliminate transmission. Smart speakers avoid this question.
  • Fire-rated assemblies: an opening in a rated ceiling between units, or in a multifamily corridor, requires a listed fire-rated speaker enclosure or a tested firestop detail. That is settled during design, not after inspection.
  • Bathrooms and outdoor areas: use speakers rated for moisture or exterior use, and cable rated for wet locations or direct burial where it runs outside.

We mark Ethernet, access point, outlet and any speaker locations on your floor plan, coordinate the rough-in with your general contractor and the licensed electrical partner who installs the outlets, and label and photograph every run before the ceiling closes.

In short

For most renovations, we advise skipping speaker wire. Smart speakers with spatial audio are the better option where Wi-Fi coverage is strong, so the money is better spent on Ethernet: run more than you need, because it is inexpensive and can carry data, power and audio. Wired speakers still suit audiophiles with specific requirements, dedicated theaters with professional AV controls, and owners who do not want microphones in the home.

Frequently asked questions

Should I run speaker wire during a renovation?

For most homes, we advise against it. Smart speakers with spatial audio are the better option where Wi-Fi coverage is strong, so we suggest running Ethernet instead. Speaker wire makes sense for audiophiles, dedicated theaters and owners who do not want microphones in the home.

Can Sonos be used with in-ceiling speakers?

Yes. A Sonos Amp drives passive in-ceiling or in-wall speakers for one zone, and the Sonos Amp Multi drives up to four zones from one chassis. Sonos Architectural speakers are designed for this use, and other passive speakers can be used within the amplifier's impedance limits.

Can in-ceiling speakers be added without opening the ceiling?

Often, yes, by fishing cable through attics, closets and joist bays that run in the right direction. In plaster ceilings this takes more labor and usually some patching and painting.

Will in-ceiling speakers disturb the neighbor upstairs?

Some sound passes through any ceiling to the unit above. Back boxes reduce sound transfer but do not eliminate it, and many co-op and condominium alteration agreements restrict speakers in a ceiling shared with the unit above or require back boxes. We review those requirements before the design is final.

Sources

5 sources
  1. Sonos bursts from the shadows with a bespoke amp, more to come (opens an external site)9to5Google
  2. Sonos Introduces Amp Multichannel Streaming Amplifier (opens an external site)Residential Systems
  3. WiiM Amp Ultra review (opens an external site)What Hi-Fi?
  4. Local Law 128 of 2024 (2025 New York City Electrical Code) (opens an external site)NYC Department of Buildings
  5. Revisions to cable requirements in the 2023 National Electrical Code (opens an external site)Cabling Installation & Maintenance

This guide reflects our experience and our interpretation of the rules as of the date it was published or last updated. Regulations, codes, incentives and the way agencies enforce them change often, and our interpretation may be incomplete or wrong. It is general information, not legal, engineering, tax or financial advice. Consult the relevant agency and a licensed professional before you plan, purchase or begin any work. Reading this guide does not make you our client and does not create any contractor, consulting or advisory relationship. Outstanding Construction Inc is not liable for any loss arising from the use of or reliance on this content, and is responsible only for work performed under a written contract signed with us.